发展职业教育还是普通教育_基于经济增长和教育(7)

108经济经纬5财经科学62012/1总286期

[15]Neuman,S.and Zi derman,A.,Vocati onal Schooling,Occupational Matchi ng and Labor M arket Earnings i n

Is rael[J].Journal of Human Resources,26(2),1991.

[16]Hollenbeck,K.,Postsecondary Education as Triage:Returns to Academic and Technical Programs[J].Eco-

nomics of Education Review,12(3),1993.

[17]Trost,R.P.and Lee,L.F.,Technical Traini ng and Earnings:a Pol ychotomous ChoiceM odelw i th Selec tiv-i

ty[J].Revie w of Economics and Statis tics,66(1),1984.

[18]Mala mud,O.and Pop-Eleches,C.,General Education vs.Vocational Traini ng:Evidence from an Economy

in Transition[R].NBER Working Paper,2008,No.14155.

[19]Kahyarara,G.and Teal, F.,The Re turns to Vocati onal Trai ning and Academic Education:Evidence fro m

Tanzania[R].World Devel opment,36(11),2008.

[20]Ps acharopoul os,G.,Vocational Education and Traini ng Today:Challenges and Responses[J].Journal of Vo-

cational Education and Training,49(3),1997.

[21]杭永宝.职业教育的经济发展贡献和成本收益问题研究[D].南京农业大学博士学位论文,

2006.

[22]蒋义.我国职业教育对经济增长和产业发展贡献研究[D].财政部财政科学研究所博士学位

论文,2010.

[23]杨毅,谭界忠.职业教育对经济增长贡献率计算研究与实证分析[J].教育与职业,2010

(23).

[24]李实,丁赛.中国城镇教育收益率的长期变动趋势[J].中国社会科学,2003(6).

[25]魏立萍,肖利宏.中等职业教育与普通高中失业者失业持续时间和再就业机会的差异分析[J].

教育与经济,2008(1).

[26]丁小浩,李莹.城镇中等职业教育就业的调查与思考[J].中国职业技术教育,2008(6).

[27]Yang,J.,The Interaction between the Sociali st Market Economy and Technical and Vocational Education in the

People.s Republic of China[D].Ph. D.Thesis,Universi ty of Manches ter,U.K,1996.

[28]Yang,J.,General or Vocati onal?The Tough Choice in the Chines e Education Policy[J].Internati onal Jour-

nal of Educational Development,18(4),1998.

[29]Dougherty,C.,Unit Cos ts and Economies of Scale i n Vocational and Technical Education:Evidence from the

People.s Republic of Chi na[J].Economics of Educati on Revie w,9(4),1990.

Shall We Develop the Vocational Education or General Education?

)))A Summary Based on the Perspective of Economic

Growth and Educational Return

Song Guanghui,Tan Qi and Chen Li

Abstract:From the point of human capital.s feature,the difference of vocational education and general e-ducation ex is ts i n the innovating cost and the period of investment return.From the perspective of economic growth,the scale of vocati onal education and the level of economic development seem to have poured U-shaped relation.The difference on the return between the two sorts of educations mostly depends on the d-i versities of the national conditi ons and individuals.Nowadays,the domestic researches on the vocational ed-ucation are insufficient by and large,and the practical research results have distinct divergence.The focus of researches on the development of the vocational education should transform from/problem0analysis to/the-ory0exploration in the future.

Key words:Vocational Education;General Education;Economic Development;Educational Return